45. The Sword and the Stone by T.H. White. 4. We did this one as a family readaloud, and it's absolutely critical to realize that White substantially revised it when he rolled it into The Once and Future King. Parts of this were as delightful as I'd remembered, parts were a little slower, and there were a couple cringily racist bits (some of which I managed to skip over verbally and a chapter with Robin Hood where the majority of the chapter is the kind of racist that will hopefully go over his head but is still pretty bad). Doing the voices is definitely a major factor. King Pellinore, I will always love you.
46. Enchanted by Alethea Kontis. 2. The combination of the author's desire to cram every fairy tale into this unnecessarily and the muddled tone that can't decide if it wants to be breezy Fractured Fairy Tales or a phantasmagorical musing on the nature of memory kind of put me off this one. Also, a number of plot points are just plain confusing.
47. The Alchemist of Souls by Anne Lyle. 3.5. There are a lot of Elizabethan fantasies out there, but this one adds some New World not-elves that actually do have enough differences from typical elves as to be worth it. There's a very confusing plot point involving multiple murders over a long period of time (where it took me a while to realize that there were two murders a generation apart instead of one time-traveling murder) but overall points for some clever originality.
48. The Stormbringer by Isabel Cooper. 3.5. Kind of generic fantasy, but with a great little twist on the romantic triangle - guy 1's been frozen in time for generations, she's freed him, guy 2 was guy 1's lover pre-frozen in time but is now a magical sword who talks in her head. Talk about awkward!
49. All Our Wrong Todays by Elan Mastai. 5. Time traveler messes up, causes dystopian hellscape, has to put it back. The twist? The dystopian hellscape he's trapped in is our current timeline.
46. Enchanted by Alethea Kontis. 2. The combination of the author's desire to cram every fairy tale into this unnecessarily and the muddled tone that can't decide if it wants to be breezy Fractured Fairy Tales or a phantasmagorical musing on the nature of memory kind of put me off this one. Also, a number of plot points are just plain confusing.
47. The Alchemist of Souls by Anne Lyle. 3.5. There are a lot of Elizabethan fantasies out there, but this one adds some New World not-elves that actually do have enough differences from typical elves as to be worth it. There's a very confusing plot point involving multiple murders over a long period of time (where it took me a while to realize that there were two murders a generation apart instead of one time-traveling murder) but overall points for some clever originality.
48. The Stormbringer by Isabel Cooper. 3.5. Kind of generic fantasy, but with a great little twist on the romantic triangle - guy 1's been frozen in time for generations, she's freed him, guy 2 was guy 1's lover pre-frozen in time but is now a magical sword who talks in her head. Talk about awkward!
49. All Our Wrong Todays by Elan Mastai. 5. Time traveler messes up, causes dystopian hellscape, has to put it back. The twist? The dystopian hellscape he's trapped in is our current timeline.